Hartford Personal Injury Attorney Guide
Menu

Car Accident Attorney in West Hartford

Car Accident Attorney in Hartford

A car accident claim usually starts simple and gets complicated fast. The other driver's insurer offers a quick settlement, medical bills keep arriving after that check clears, and questions come up about lost wages, vehicle damage, and whether the offer actually covers future treatment. Car accident attorneys handle that whole process: dealing with insurance adjusters, gathering police reports and medical records, calculating what a claim is actually worth, negotiating a settlement, and filing suit if the insurer won't offer a fair number. We've listed 31 firms in West Hartford that take on this kind of work.

What to look for in a car accident attorney

Not every firm handles cases the same way, so it's worth checking a few things before you sign a retainer agreement. Look at how much of their practice is actually auto accident cases versus general personal injury or other litigation. Ask who will handle your file day to day, since larger firms sometimes hand cases off to junior associates or paralegals after the initial consultation. Confirm the fee structure up front (most work on contingency, meaning no fee unless you recover money) and ask what percentage they take and whether that changes if the case goes to trial. It also helps to ask how they handle costs like expert witnesses or accident reconstruction if your case needs them.

How our scoring works

Our ranking weighs factors like experience with auto accident claims specifically, responsiveness, client feedback, and how a firm's track record compares to others in the area. You can see the full breakdown of criteria on our methodology page, and the ranked list itself is at best personal injury attorneys in West Hartford.

Find car accident attorney in West Hartford in your area

No cost, no commitment. Describe your case and we will connect you with qualified attorneys.

Request quotes

All car accident attorney in West Hartford, ranked by score and relevance

We found 34 businesses offering car accident attorney in West Hartford; 33 met the criteria for the scored directory. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is car accident attorney, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.

Rosenthal Law Firm, LLC
5.0(132)✓ Google-verified

Edward Rosenthal and his team consistently win clients money beyond initial offers by standing firm against insurance companies. Clients report being kept updated via call and text, walked through each step clearly, and treated with genuine care from intake to settlement. The firm handles car accidents, motorcycle crashes, slip and fall cases, and worker's compensation. Reviewers single out Rosenthal's professionalism, responsiveness to questions, and willingness to wait out settlements rather than rush to a quick close. One client's case took four years; another secured five times the initial settlement offer. No complaints appear in any review.

RisCassi & Davis, P.C.
4.9(141)✓ Google-verified

Sean Stokes, Paul Iannaccone, John Houlihan, Chris, and Ryan Sullivan handle accident cases with genuine care, returning calls within 30 minutes and keeping clients informed at each stage. Clients consistently praise the team's professionalism and ability to deliver outcomes-including complex multi-year settlements-while treating people as individuals, not case numbers.

Law Office of Diana Dafa, LLC
5.0(50)✓ Google-verified

All 15 reviews are five-star, with clients consistently praising Diana Dafa's care, professionalism, and ability to make stressful legal processes feel manageable. Reviewers highlight her clear communication, availability to answer questions, and attention to detail, particularly in immigration cases that resulted in green cards and citizenship approvals.

Goetz Law, LLC
4.9(59)✓ Google-verified

Clients describe Goetz Law as consistently responsive and attentive. Tim Goetz and his team including Alexandra Dzen and Kelly Chrostowski earn repeated praise for explaining complex legal matters clearly, handling estate plans and real estate transactions efficiently, and going above and beyond on landlord and family law matters. Attorney Dzen has returned calls within 30 minutes and completed estate plans in under two weeks. Landlords mention peace and reassurance during stressful evictions. Reviewers highlight fair pricing and a professional, accessible approach that makes legal work feel straightforward rather than overwhelming.

Goff Law Group
4.7(591)✓ Google-verified

Goff Law Group earns strong client loyalty through staff who answer quickly, communicate clearly, and fight for settlements that often exceed what clients expected. Reviewers name lawyers like Chace, Candy, Zach Gain, and Pam Cameron as genuinely supportive through hit-and-runs, slip-and-falls, and workplace injuries. Two persistent caveats emerge: early settlement offers that undersell cases, and a documented case of withheld client records spanning a decade. The firm's aggressive advertising footprint also drew complaint from one repeat reviewer who argued resources should focus on case quality rather than billboards.

Find car accident attorney in West Hartford in your area

No cost, no commitment. Describe your case and we will connect you with qualified attorneys.

Request quotes
Furey, Donovan, Cooney & Dyer, PC
5.0(23)✓ Google-verified

Every review is five-star. Clients consistently praise Pat Cooney and the firm for being accessible, explaining legal matters in plain language, and delivering strong outcomes on personal injury and car accident cases. Reviewers report feeling genuinely supported and kept informed throughout the process, with many returning for multiple matters over years.

Kennedy, Johnson, Schwab & Roberge, P.C.
5.0(28)✓ Google-verified

Clients consistently report thorough, compassionate representation backed by quick communication and careful attention to their circumstances. Named attorneys including Kennedy, Schwab, Annecchino, Roberge, and Koch earned particular praise for explaining processes clearly, staying accessible during recovery, and negotiating settlements clients found fair. The firm handles car accidents, wrongful death, falls, and workplace injuries across multiple towns in the Hartford area. Reviewers highlight the willingness to take on difficult cases, coordinate with other counsel when needed, and manage complex multi-party incidents. Staff including Andrea Onofrio and Maura Black earned specific recognition for support and follow-through.

Wein & Palermo

#8Wein & Palermo

80 low data
4.8(47)✓ Google-verified

Clients consistently praise John Palermo and the firm for staying on top of cases and fighting to get results. Reviewers note the team keeps them informed without having to chase updates, speaks Spanish, and treats people with genuine care throughout their cases.

Kurien Ouellette LLC

#9Kurien Ouellette LLC

78 low data
5.0(20)✓ Google-verified

Clients report exceptional responsiveness from Nick Ouellette and his team, with staff available outside standard hours and returning calls within hours. Beyond legal expertise, reviewers consistently mention feeling valued as individuals rather than case files, with the firm taking time to understand family situations and employment needs. Multiple matters were resolved quickly and favorably, including cases dismissed within weeks and franchise purchases handled with thorough guidance. Staff members like Erica Basil and attorneys Matthew Dallas and Matthew Gordon are named for their professionalism and accessibility.

Hardy Law Group
4.6(116)✓ Google-verified

Clients report starkly different experiences. Successful divorce and family law clients praise Hardy's fierce negotiation, transparent communication throughout proceedings, and ability to calm anxious clients while delivering favorable settlements. Multiple reviewers credit him with maximizing their outcomes in contested divorces. However, dissatisfied clients describe him as evasive, dismissive, and prone to missed deadlines. Several paid substantial fees (7500 to 8000 dollars) and report minimal follow-up, ignored calls, late court appearances, and negligent filings that triggered contempt charges. The pattern suggests inconsistent service depending on case complexity or perceived ease of resolution.

Costello, Coombes & Brown, LLP
5.0(17)✓ Google-verified

Five-star reviews across 17 cases show clients consistently return and refer. Frank Costello and Jeremy Brown gain specific praise for fighting hard, explaining legal details plainly, and responding within 24 hours. Workers compensation cases dominate feedback; clients value the firm's certification, willingness to keep cases unsettled until satisfied, and treating them as people rather than case numbers.

Cohen, Burns, Hard & Paul
4.5(32)✓ Google-verified

Cohen, Burns, Hard & Paul earns consistent praise for quick responses and professional handling across real estate, business, and personal legal matters. Named attorneys like Eric Hard and Kevin Burns deliver accessible service and expert guidance clients trust for decades.

Keily Mira Law
4.9(125)✓ Google-verified

Keily Mira Law handles real estate closings, estate work, and family matters with strong client rapport and quick responses. Attorneys Paul Keily, Jennifer Mira, and Jonathan Aubin are named for going beyond what's expected, guiding clients through details with patience. One serious complaint describes ghosting and surprise billing after a HOA representation, though most reviewers praise reliability and genuine care for their situations.

Law Office of John T. Scully
4.2(5)✓ Google-verified

Clients report strong results on auto accidents and cases other lawyers declined, with Scully known for personal rapport and aggressive pursuit of settlements. One minimal complaint noted.

Law Office of Peter J Casey LLC
4.0(5)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers value Peter Casey's willingness to fight hard for clients and explain options plainly. Long-term clients highlight his knowledge and straightforward approach across personal injury and estate matters.

Law Offices of David Seidman, P.C
5.0(4)✓ Google-verified

All four Google reviews award five stars, praising Attorney Seidman's responsiveness, legal expertise, and ability to explain process clearly. Clients report gaining confidence through his dedication to their cases. Limited review volume prevents deeper insight into specific services or outcomes.

Find car accident attorney in West Hartford in your area

No cost, no commitment. Describe your case and we will connect you with qualified attorneys.

Request quotes
Law Offices of Michele A. Nath, LLC
5.0(6)✓ Google-verified

All six reviews award five stars. Clients consistently praise Michele Nath for responding quickly, staying in touch during their cases, and showing genuine care. Reviewers highlight her calm approach, professionalism, and willingness to explain the process step by step.

StangerLaw LLC

#18StangerLaw LLC

62 low data
4.2(13)✓ Google-verified

Most reviewers praise the firm's attorneys as knowledgeable and personally attentive, with senior partners named Stanger and Stanfield earning specific recognition for complex cases. However, recent complaints highlight scheduling failures and inconsistent client access, which undercuts trust. Evidence is limited by age and breadth across multiple practice areas.

Gersten & Gersten, LLP

#19Gersten & Gersten, LLP

62 low data
4.1(13)✓ Google-verified

Most reviewers praise Karen Gersten's legal skill and genuine concern for clients in family cases. However, one detailed complaint accuses her of acting without consulting clients beforehand and pursuing tactics that backfired for families she represented.

Law Office of Robert J. Kor
5.0(3)✓ Google-verified

Three five-star reviews consistently highlight Kor's direct communication, swift case resolution, and willingness to prioritize client welfare over settlement size. Clients describe feeling reassured by his confidence and experience during stressful legal situations.

Kimberly A Graham Law Office LLC
4.6(8)✓ Google-verified

All three reviews rate the office at five stars. Clients consistently praise Attorney Graham's personable approach and attentiveness to their cases, with limited but consistent evidence of quality legal work.

BBB Attorneys, LLC

#22BBB Attorneys, LLC

56 low data
2.3(3)✓ Google-verified

Two recent one-star reviews describe a firm that delayed cases extensively, charged heavily for minimal progress, and left clients feeling ignored. Communication was hard to get, and both reviewers lost their cases and strongly advise against hiring them.

Peter S Gersten, Gersten Law Offices, LLC
5.0(13)

Peter Gersten handles car accidents with consistent attention to detail and client welfare. Reviewers praise his responsiveness, transparency about case progress, and willingness to secure strong settlements while treating clients as individuals rather than transactions.

Serrano Law Firm, LLC

#24Serrano Law Firm, LLC

53 low data
3.9(26)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers who worked with the firm on personal injury and workers' compensation cases consistently praise John Serrano as knowledgeable and responsive. Multiple complaints across family law, immigration, and criminal work describe unresponsiveness, nondelivery, and refusal to engage after payment. Review evidence is limited in scope and unevenly distributed across service lines.

Law Offices of Paul S. Taub
4.0(4)✓ Google-verified

One reviewer praised Paul Taub for professionalism; another left a one-star rating with no detail provided. Review evidence is limited.

Duane Lueders Law Offices
4.6(9)

Duane Lueders handles motor vehicle and personal injury cases with strong communication and follow-up. One repeat client complained about low settlement offers and broken promises, though most reviewers praise fair compensation and quick case setup.

Reinken Law Firm - Sexual Abuse and Assault Lawyer
No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Review evidence is limited. The firm specializes in sexual abuse claims involving institutions, professionals, and family members, with service areas spanning Connecticut and nationwide. No reviews are available to assess client experience or outcomes.

Aeton Law Partners

#32Aeton Law Partners

28 low data
No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Review evidence for Aeton Law Partners is limited. The business lists personal injury among its services on their website alongside broader corporate and commercial work, though no customer reviews are available to assess their performance in this area.

Halpin & Mostowy

#33Halpin & Mostowy

24 low data
No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Get quotes from our featured partners

How many quotes would you like?

When you send this enquiry, you agree that we share it with providers who are relevant to your request.

When you submit a form on this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can complete the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published methodology and are not affected by referral fees.

Common questions about car accident attorney

How much does a car accident attorney cost?
Most car accident attorneys work on a contingency fee, typically 33% of the settlement if the case resolves before a lawsuit is filed and up to 40% if it goes to litigation or trial. You generally pay nothing up front, and the fee comes out of the final recovery. Some firms also deduct case costs (medical record requests, expert fees) separately from their percentage, so ask exactly how that's calculated before signing.
Do I actually need a lawyer for a minor car accident?
If there are no injuries and the property damage is minor, many people handle the claim themselves directly with the insurance company. A lawyer becomes worth it once you have any injury requiring ongoing treatment, a disputed fault determination, or an insurer offering less than your medical bills and lost wages add up to. Attorneys typically get involved once it's clear the claim is more than a quick fender-bender payout.
What should I expect during the process?
After the initial consultation, the attorney typically sends a letter of representation to the insurer, gathers medical records and bills as your treatment progresses, and waits until you've reached maximum medical improvement before demanding a settlement, since settling too early can undervalue future treatment needs. If negotiations stall, the firm may file suit, though most car accident cases still settle before trial. The timeline can run anywhere from a few months for straightforward claims to over a year for serious injury cases.
How can I judge whether a firm does good work?
Ask directly how many car accident cases they've handled and what typical settlement ranges look like for injuries similar to yours. Check whether they're willing to take a case to trial if needed, since firms known for settling everything quickly sometimes leave money on the table. Client reviews mentioning communication and responsiveness are a useful signal too, since a common complaint in this field is going weeks without hearing from your own attorney.

Last updated 2026-09-15