Hartford Personal Injury Attorney Guide
Menu

Personal injury attorneys in New Britain Downtown: ranked picks

personal injury attorney in New Britain Downtown, Hartford

Downtown New Britain has a solid cluster of personal injury firms, from long-running Connecticut names to smaller family-run practices. The rankings below weigh review volume, rating consistency, and what clients actually say about communication and outcomes; see our methodology for how each score is built.

Several firms here handle overlapping caseloads: car accident claims, workers' compensation, and slip-and-fall cases tied to the city's older buildings and sidewalks. A few practices, like Ericson Scalise & Mangan, also cover estate and real estate work alongside injury cases, which is worth knowing if you want one firm for multiple legal needs.

38 businesses, scored on rating, review volume, recency, sentiment and listing completeness. How we score › · View on map ›

At a glance

#BusinessScoreRatingFromBest for
1McCoy & McCoy934.9 (260)—car accident
2Welcome Law Firm: Hartford Personal Injury & Immigration Lawyer925 (129)—car accident
3Bert McDowell Injury Law, LLC915 (114)—car accident
4Carter Mario Injury Lawyers914.8 (236)—Long-standing CT track record
5Forrest Legal894.9 (93)—car accident
6Law Offices of Mark E. Salomone & Morelli895 (91)—Fast, fair settlements
7Ferry Law885 (62)—Personalized, long-term advocacy
8Appleton & Appleton LLC885 (60)—car accident
9Kocian Law Group854.8 (81)—Workers' comp and follow-up care
10Chaffin Luhana LLP Injury Lawyers854.9 (69)—car accident
11Brandon J Broderick, Personal Injury Attorney at Law854.7 (62)—Straightforward intake process
12Brown Paindiris & Scott, LLP834.7 (43)—car accident
13Rob Levine Law - Personal Injury & Disability Lawyers814.9 (115)—car accident
14Weber Carrier Chace LLP814.5 (43)—Veteran attorneys, direct access
15Michael Kelly Injury Lawyers795 (23)—car accident
16The Law Offices of Januszewski McQuillan and DeNigris, LLP704.4 (7)—car accident
17Law Offices of Ericson, Scalise & Mangan, PC874.9 (103)—Injury plus estate or real estate needs
18The Rivera Law Group, LLC664.9 (7)—Spanish-speaking, family-run service
19Law Offices of Brian J. Mongelluzzo, LLC614.6 (18)—car accident
20Rembish & LaSaracina, LLC604.4 (13)—car accident
21Forghany Law P.C.584.2 (31)—car accident
22Barbieri Law LLC714.4 (13)—car accident
23Martin M. Rizzi554.8 (5)—car accident
24Lynne A Ustach Law Offices543.5 (8)—car accident
25Law Offices of James F. Kane545 (3)—car accident
26Petroski & Rizzi535 (3)—car accident
27Motley Rice LLC - Hartford535 (1)—car accident
28Attorney John Hagel505 (1)—car accident
29Law Offices of William J. Sweeney Jr, LLC493 (2)—car accident
30Michalik Bauer Silvia & Ciccarillo LLP563 (2)—car accident
31Wisniowski & Sullivan LLC514.4 (7)—car accident
32Law Offices of Levine & Levine391.4 (10)—car accident
33Jeffrey Glassman Injury Lawyers32——car accident
34Cellino Law Injury Attorneys30——car accident
35Buckley Wynne & Parese28——car accident
36Law Offices of Pat Brown28——car accident
37Tuesley Hall Konopa, LLP24——no win no fee
38The Law Office of Evan Fitzpatrick, LLC21——no win no fee

Ranked picks

1
McCoy & McCoy

McCoy & McCoy

score 93/100
4.9 from 260 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationkept informedaggressive advocacy

Attorney Parrot, Angela Edwards, and their staff consistently respond within hours and keep clients informed at every turn, even when insurance companies delay.

2
Welcome Law Firm: Hartford Personal Injury & Immigration Lawyer

Welcome Law Firm: Hartford Personal Injury & Immigration Lawyer

score 92/100
5 from 129 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationknowledgeable staffkept informed

All 129 reviews are five-star, reflecting consistent satisfaction with case outcomes and client service.

3
Bert McDowell Injury Law, LLC

Bert McDowell Injury Law, LLC

score 91/100
5 from 114 reviews
car accidentwon caseresponsive communicationknowledgeable staff

Reviewers consistently report winning cases and feeling supported throughout.

4
Carter Mario Injury Lawyers

Carter Mario Injury Lawyers

score 91/100
4.8 from 236 reviews
Long-standing CT track recordresponsive communicationkept informedpersonalized attention

Over 30 years in practice with reviewers consistently saying staff kept them updated and prioritized recovery over case volume.

5
Forrest Legal

Forrest Legal

score 89/100
4.9 from 93 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationknowledgeable staffkept informed

Reviewers consistently report that Attorney Matthew Forrest and his team handle diminished value and vehicle accident claims with ease and skill.

6
Law Offices of Mark E. Salomone & Morelli

Law Offices of Mark E. Salomone & Morelli

score 89/100
5 from 91 reviews
Fastfair settlementsresponsive communicationknowledgeable staff

A perfect 5-star average with clients crediting named staff for clear upfront explanations and settlements resolved in months.

7
Ferry Law

Ferry Law

score 88/100
5 from 62 reviews
Personalizedlong-term advocacyresponsive communicationcompassionate

High rating with clients naming Kevin Ferry and Monique Foley for combining strong negotiation with genuine, ongoing support.

8
Appleton & Appleton LLC

Appleton & Appleton LLC

score 88/100
5 from 60 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationkept informedcompassionate

Peter Appleton and his team deliver thorough representation without overwhelming clients.

9
Kocian Law Group

Kocian Law Group

score 85/100
4.8 from 81 reviews
Workers' comp and follow-up careresponsive communicationkept informedcompassionate

Clients highlight Adam Meltsner's hands-on management, including follow-up after medical appointments, though one review flagged inconsistent service.

10
Chaffin Luhana LLP Injury Lawyers

Chaffin Luhana LLP Injury Lawyers

score 85/100
4.9 from 69 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationcompassionateknowledgeable staff

Reviews paint a picture of a firm that combines speed with care.

11
Brandon J Broderick, Personal Injury Attorney at Law

Brandon J Broderick, Personal Injury Attorney at Law

score 85/100
4.7 from 62 reviews
Straightforward intake processresponsive communicationknowledgeable staffkept informed

Callers describe responsive staff, especially Elizabeth and Lina, who explain the claims process without friction.

12
Brown Paindiris & Scott, LLP

Brown Paindiris & Scott, LLP

score 83/100
4.7 from 43 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationknowledgeable staffcompassionate

Clients consistently describe feeling supported by a team that listens closely and fights hard for their interests.

13
Rob Levine Law - Personal Injury & Disability Lawyers

Rob Levine Law - Personal Injury & Disability Lawyers

score 81/100
4.9 from 115 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationpoor communicationcompassionate

Most reviewers credit specific case managers (Yessica, Sebastian, Valentina) for responsive, caring handling of disability and personal injury claims.

14
Weber Carrier Chace LLP

Weber Carrier Chace LLP

score 81/100
4.5 from 43 reviews
Veteran attorneysdirect accessresponsive communicationcompassionate

Clients point to Robert Weber and Michael Carrier by name for patient, transparent handling and many return for repeat matters.

15
Michael Kelly Injury Lawyers

Michael Kelly Injury Lawyers

score 79/100
5 from 23 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationkept informedcompassionate

Staff treat clients like family from the first call, handling paperwork and case setup efficiently without confusion.

16
The Law Offices of Januszewski McQuillan and DeNigris, LLP

The Law Offices of Januszewski McQuillan and DeNigris, LLP

score 70/100
4.4 from 7 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationcompassionatetransparent fees

Martin McQuillan and the firm earn consistent praise for honesty, responsiveness, and clear explanations of the legal process.

17
Law Offices of Ericson, Scalise & Mangan, PC

Law Offices of Ericson, Scalise & Mangan, PC

score 87/100
4.9 from 103 reviews
Injury plus estate or real estate needsresponsive communicationknowledgeable staffpersonalized attention

Strong rating from 100 reviews and praise for Robert Scalise's guidance, tempered by one complaint about missed callbacks.

18
The Rivera Law Group, LLC

The Rivera Law Group, LLC

score 66/100
4.9 from 7 reviews
Spanish-speakingfamily-run serviceresponsive communicationprofessional demeanor

A small but strong 4.9 rating from a family-run firm available seven days a week, though review volume is still limited.

19
Law Offices of Brian J. Mongelluzzo, LLC

Law Offices of Brian J. Mongelluzzo, LLC

score 61/100
4.6 from 18 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationcompassionatekept informed

Clients report strong personal attention and consistent case updates from Brian Mongelluzzo's team, with several praising the firm's warmth and respect during difficult times.

20
Rembish & LaSaracina, LLC

Rembish & LaSaracina, LLC

score 60/100
4.4 from 13 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationcompassionateknowledgeable staff

Reviewers consistently praise Kinga Kostaniak for family law and real estate work, noting her knowledge, empathy, and clear guidance.

21
Forghany Law P.C.

Forghany Law P.C.

score 58/100
4.2 from 31 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationcompassionatetransparent fees

Most clients praise Forghany Law for attentive, compassionate handling of bankruptcy and debt cases, noting quick responses and smooth processes.

22
Barbieri Law LLC

Barbieri Law LLC

score 71/100
4.4 from 13 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationkept informedknowledgeable staff

Reviewers consistently praise quick responses and clear guidance through legal processes.

23
Martin M. Rizzi

Martin M. Rizzi

score 55/100
4.8 from 5 reviews
car accidentknowledgeable staffresponsive communication

Martin Rizzi has earned consistent five-star reviews from clients who value his straightforward competence and long-term reliability.

24
Lynne A Ustach Law Offices

Lynne A Ustach Law Offices

score 54/100
3.5 from 8 reviews
car accidentresponsive communicationcompassionateknowledgeable staff

Five-star reviewers call her a trusted guide through divorce, real estate, and personal injury matters.

25
Law Offices of James F. Kane

Law Offices of James F. Kane

score 54/100
5 from 3 reviews
car accidentknowledgeable staffresponsive communicationcompassionate

All three five-star reviews praise Attorney Kane's knowledge, honesty, and hands-on involvement.

26
Petroski & Rizzi

Petroski & Rizzi

score 53/100
5 from 3 reviews
car accidentknowledgeable staffaggressive advocacytransparent fees

One reviewer called John an expert and tenacious advocate worth the trip; another praised fair prices and service.

27
Motley Rice LLC - Hartford

Motley Rice LLC - Hartford

score 53/100
5 from 1 reviews
car accident

One five-star review from over a decade ago called the firm "intriguing as expected," offering limited insight into current service quality or client experience.

28
Attorney John Hagel

Attorney John Hagel

score 50/100
5 from 1 reviews
car accidentknowledgeable staffprofessional demeanor

A real estate agent with seven years of professional contact praises Attorney Hagel's legal knowledge, accuracy, and ability to deliver correct answers consistently and keep clients satisfied.

29
Law Offices of William J. Sweeney Jr, LLC

Law Offices of William J. Sweeney Jr, LLC

score 49/100
3 from 2 reviews
car accident

Limited review evidence: the business holds a 3.0 average across 2 Google reviews with a split rating spread (50% five-star, 50% one/two-star).

30
Michalik Bauer Silvia & Ciccarillo LLP

Michalik Bauer Silvia & Ciccarillo LLP

score 56/100
3 from 2 reviews
car accidentprofessional demeanor

One reviewer from 2005 praised an attorney for securing SSI benefits; another recent reviewer found the listed phone number non-functional.

31
Wisniowski & Sullivan LLC

Wisniowski & Sullivan LLC

score 51/100
4.4 from 7 reviews
car accidentprofessional demeanorknowledgeable staffresponsive communication

Most reviewers praise the firm's professional approach and clear guidance through legal steps.

32
Law Offices of Levine & Levine

Law Offices of Levine & Levine

score 39/100
1.4 from 10 reviews
car accidentunresponsivepoor communicationfelt like a number

Ten reviews average 1.4 stars, with 90% one or two-star ratings.

33
Jeffrey Glassman Injury Lawyers

Jeffrey Glassman Injury Lawyers

score 32/100
car accident

Jeffrey Glassman Injury Lawyers operates from Downtown Hartford and claims 30+ years in personal injury law.

34
Cellino Law Injury Attorneys

Cellino Law Injury Attorneys

score 30/100
car accident

Review evidence is not available for this firm.

35
Buckley Wynne & Parese

Buckley Wynne & Parese

score 28/100
car accident

No review text available for this business.

36
Law Offices of Pat Brown

Law Offices of Pat Brown

score 28/100
car accident

Review evidence is limited.

37
Tuesley Hall Konopa, LLP

Tuesley Hall Konopa, LLP

score 24/100
no win no fee

Review evidence is limited.

38
The Law Office of Evan Fitzpatrick, LLC

The Law Office of Evan Fitzpatrick, LLC

score 21/100
no win no fee

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Last updated 2026-09-15