
Law Offices of Andrew J. Cates, LLC
Andrew Cates listens, explains things clearly, and returns calls even on weekends. Reviewers credit him with winning settlements they felt they deserved and treating them more like friends than cases.
Five-star reviews highlight thorough, professional service from Attorney O'Neil and named staff Cathy and Patricia, with clients reporting clear guidance and strong advocacy in family matters. One-star complaints span several years and centre on phone reception staff being dismissive, rushed, or rude during initial inquiries, which overshadows the firm's legal reputation.
Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.

Andrew Cates listens, explains things clearly, and returns calls even on weekends. Reviewers credit him with winning settlements they felt they deserved and treating them more like friends than cases.

One reviewer praised C. Michael Budlong as aggressive and professional, securing a favorable lawsuit outcome. Evidence is limited to a single five-year-old review.

Clients consistently describe Patrick Tomasiewicz as genuinely invested in their cases, from taking on serious felonies to complex civil litigation. The firm's strength lies in aggressive defense combined with steady communication, regular updates, and a team that treats people as individuals rather than case numbers. Medical malpractice and criminal defense emerge as particular strengths. A client secured a settlement against a major medical institution after years of skillful case management. Another saw felony charges reduced and dismissed through thorough expert witness preparation. Staff and paralegals receive equal praise for responsiveness and follow-through.
Last updated 2026-07-15